Pumpkin Pie Milkshake Recipe

This milkshake brings all the boys to the yard. Just kidding!  

What's fun about this treat is you can use a store-bought pumpkin pie and it's super easy to whip up a big batch of these for friends. Or you can use a homemade pumpkin pie (maybe the left over few pieces) and enjoy this sweet and decadent dessert.

We made our own pumpkin pie (first one of the season) and my kitchen instantly smelled like autumn. I used a slightly adapted version of Paula Deen's recipe. The only changes I made were to use 1/2 cup sugar and 1/2 brown sugar (instead of just 1 cup of sugar, I like the added flavor of using some brown sugar). And I used 2 eggs instead of 1 egg + 2 egg yolks (I thought this didn't seem necessary, and in my opinion the pie turned out great!).

Once you've made your pie let is cool for a few hours or overnight. To make a single milkshake blend together 1 slice of pumpkin pie, 2 cups vanilla ice cream and 1 to 1 1/2 cups milk. If you are making multiple milkshakes at once simply double or triple this recipe to suit your guest list.

We garnished our milkshakes with a few mini pumpkin pies I had made, just for fun!

xo, emma + elsie

Comments

[irene]

ow really looks delicious! :) wanna try! :)

http://lovesimplegreen.blogspot.com/

[Katrina]

Weird but yummm!

[Elisha]

I want to make this immediately! Step 1: replace the blender that I shattered last week.... hopefully there is one at the thrift store!

[Rae Veda]

YUM! That looks so yummy. Do you think you could use a food processor instead of a blender? XO,RaeVeda

http://aneclecticheap.blogspot.com/

[Katie maye]

Is it cazy that I want to bake a pie just for the milkshakes??!! Haha! Looks soo good

[Lauren]

Oh no! These look dangerous! Both my husband and I love pumpkin pie, so I started growing pumpkins this year and the insane heat we had (or some kind of disease, I'm not an expert gardener) killed them off. Now I'm waiting for them to show up at the farmers' market. This is a great idea for leftover pumpkin pie! I'll have to try it.

[pushups with polish]

YES! it's fall, this is my first pumpkin recipe ive seen. makes me feel all warm and cozy inside! can't wait to try it and feed my obsession xxo

[bootoagooseblog]

This sounds very intriguing! I would love to try it. Although last time i had pumkin pie i didn't enjoy it that much.MMaybe it will taste better in milkshake form!

[Kacie]

WHAT!!! That looks AMAZING! Happy Fall to you two lovely ladies!

Kacie
http://www.acollectionofpassions.com/

[Charissa Steyn]

I LOVE PUMPKIN!! And this looks too delicious for words!! ;)

[Mandy @ Miss Indie]

Wow wow! I can't wait to make these!!

[frutti]

What a shame pumpkin pie isn't popular in my country! If only I had an oven...
Your piece of cake looks delicious!

[Lori Souter]

Awesome! I am so ready for fall and some pumpkin pie! This is such a cute way to have such a special treat!

Lori

[Sara Sophia]

You both make me so happy.
And so do these milkshakes.

My son who is reading over my shoulder says, "MAMA. CAN WE GO MAKE THOSE NOW???"

:)

--Sara Sophia

[Cupkay]

"This milkshake brings all the boys to the yard. Just kidding! " < hahaha!
I wasn't expecting to read that after seeing the picture...

This sounds so delicious, I'm going to have to whip a couple of these up... never heard of them, very neat.

Thanks for sharing!

xo

[Natalya]

SOOOO creative, and OMFG those looks yummy!! XOXO, www.NatalyasCloset.com

[Meagan]

I love Pumpkin and I bet these milkshakes are delicious. :)

[Annalise Furman]

These look too good to eat/drink! But I might just make an exception because I LOVE pumpkin pie. You have me drooling over here.
XOXO

[Kim Waite]

These look absolutely delicious! Definitely will be making some of these this fall. My favorite season!

[Corrine]

This is great! I can't wait to make these. I had been hearing that McDonald's (gag) was coming out with a Pumpkin Pie Milkshake & contemplated trying to make a recipe of my own so I didn't have to go there. Thanks for doing the hard work for me!